Irmo Firefighter James Muller, 25, died in the line of duty (reports below) in a fire at the Tropical Ridge Apartments in May 2023. He was part of a mutual aid response from the Irmo Fire District after the Columbia-Richland Fire Department had already been at the scene.
Nearly two years later, Emma Muller filed a wrongful death lawsuit claiming CRFD’s use of deck guns and master streams caused a roof to collapse while her husband was still inside. Among other allegations, the lawsuit also claims a mayday call was mishandled, causing James Muller to be trapped for nearly 45 minutes while he was still conscious before being freed.
In the Sept. 21 filing, Emma Muller’s attorneys seek to depose 26 city employees and officials, including CRFD Chief Aubrey Jenkins. Documents state that the city listed 57 potential witnesses without contact information, and then ignored multiple requests to schedule those depositions. Both parties initially set an August date for the depositions, but Muller’s attorneys claim the city asked in late July to postpone those to October. The plaintiffs agreed to that.
Then, on Sept. 18, Muller’s attorneys claim the city abruptly asked to postpone the depositions again, this time to January 2027. The reasons cited were “court summons” and “jury duty”…


