COLUMBIA — In the ongoing legal battle over who must bear responsibility for the 2023 death of Irmo Firefighter J. Muller, the Irmo Fire District is now calling for the resignation of both Columbia Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief of Operations Anthony Holloway.
In an offer of judgment filed on Nov. 17, lawyers for the Irmo Fire District laid out settlement terms to bring the case between Columbia and Irmo to a close:
- Terminate the employment of Aubrey Jenkins and Anthony Holloway, effective immediately
- Reimburse all of the Irmo Fire District’s legal fees, totaling upwards of $40,000
- Jenkins issuing a written, public apology for false allegations that Irmo Fire employees gave false statements to any agency investigating the fire
- Holloway issuing a written, public apology for false allegations that Sloane Valentino, Irmo’s assistant chief of operations, influenced the writing of the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health report.
While Irmo is not named in the original lawsuit filed by Muller’s widow, Emma Muller, the city of Columbia filed a third-party suit against Irmo, arguing that the fire district should be liable for any damages Columbia might be ordered to pay.
The lawsuit has been playing out over the last year and a half, and the city has been accused of purposefully “stonewalling” efforts to move the process along.
The city has 20 days to respond to the offer, which could include countering with its own terms. If the city rejects the terms, the court could hold it responsible for paying all of the Irmo Fire District’s legal fees incurred from that point forward if it loses the lawsuit.
Lawyers for Irmo’s Fire District declined to comment, citing pending litigation.
Representatives for the city of Columbia and the Columbia-Richland Fire Department didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.
Allegations against Columbia Fire
Emma Muller’s lawsuit — which is being handled by Brian Barnwell from the firm Rikard and Protopapas, LLC — alleges that Columbia’s use of powerful “deck guns,” spraying copious amounts of water on the roof of an already compromised structure, led to the collapse. The lawsuit also holds the Columbia-Richland Fire Department responsible for a chaotic scene that resulted in Muller’s mayday call being ignored, leaving him trapped for at least 45 minutes.
A 2025 report from the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health found that this miscommunication, a failure to keep track of personnel at the scene, and inadequate knowledge of the building’s structural integrity led to Muller’s death. The agency assessed the Columbia and Irmo fire departments each with $3,600 in fines and citations.
In September, Muller’s lawyers filed an emergency motion after the city attempted to push back depositions for 26 firefighters until next year, almost two years after the lawsuit was filed in April 2025. This follows the city’s repeated refusal to turn over information in discovery, forcing the firm to ask the court to step in multiple times, Barnwell said.
Depositions are underway, and the case could go to trial by spring. Fifth Circuit Court Judge Daniel Coble assigned himself to the case.
Recently, it was alleged in documents included in an Oct. 16 filing by Muller’s lawyers that the city of Columbia threatened to stop providing assistance to Irmo’s fire department, as stipulated by a 2012 mutual aid agreement between the two departments, if they did not comply with the city’s demands to bear some financial responsibility in the lawsuit.
The city of Columbia argued that if such aid stopped, Irmo residents “would be forced to incur increased insurance rates and property taxes,” according to the filing.
While lawyers for the Irmo Fire District confirmed these statements were made in court, the city of Columbia said those claims are “categorically false.”
That same filing also alleged the city recently contacted federal investigators at the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, asking them to alter their line-of-duty death report in the case.
Another lawsuit
It’s not the only lawsuit Jenkins is tied up in regarding the fatal fire.
In June, Jenkins filed a defamation lawsuit against the Professional Firefighters Association of South Carolina and its president, Roger Odachowski. Jenkins claimed the association was wrongfully blaming him for Muller’s death.
The lawsuit states that, through a press release and various social media posts in 2023, the association accused him of “years of neglect and deficiencies,” claiming that Jenkins’ leadership resulted in “severe staffing issues, nonfunctioning apparatus, delayed response times, NFPA safety violations” and that he “continues to put residents, businesses, and firefighters at extreme risk.”
The association released a statement on June 25 denying the lawsuit’s merit.
On Nov. 19, a Richland County Court will consider a possible dismissal of the case.
Earlier this year, The Post and Courier revealed that under Jenkins’ leadership, the Columbia-Richland Fire Department routinely ignored years of mounting maintenance requests in its fire stations, leading to questions around the safety of the structures and the quality of life for the firefighters living in them.
The department said it will need over $175 million to fix these issues. The department also admitted that it’s understaffed by over 100 positions.


